ForewordOn occasion I will invite a guest author to contribute to the blog, as I believe it's important to get some feedback from non-FTMs on how our community is viewed.
I received an email response to a post I had made on here, LGB-T? from Krisiswriting. She told me that she identified as a lesbian and wanted to respond to the points I had raised in my post regards the lesbian community. I was quite taken with her response and asked if I could post it here to let you all see. Her response is below, enjoy!
KeltikTo Commit Pronoun "Fellany"
While reading the blog at
http://thetwordblog.blogspot.com, I felt an unfamiliar urge to get involved with the conversation and reply. I understand that this blog is only for Trans Men, but since the subject of “L” came up and I was reading the blog not as trans, but as a lesbian who is interested in the subject, why not have a little give and take. First of all, I want to say that I am one of those guilty as charged (see the post “LGB-T?”). I’m not an Alex Parks drone; I’m one of those that commit the pronoun sins, mostly towards MTFs as you pointed out. It is not in hatred, it is in ignorance and confusion.
I’d like to think that lesbians are the more thoughtful type, more prone to PC, but this is a tricky category for them/us/me. As perhaps a more independent female sometimes than a straight “breeder”, more attracted to scientific method, more interested in knowing the right answer as so many of us were the only girls raising hands in class, we have this inherent need to “call a spade a spade” when we have further information about a shovel. We are “know it alls”, we may have even been the bottom feeders, the low girls on the totem pole, and no one was below us because even the nerdy boys had their maleness to triumph over us. Many of us were made fun of or felt like lepers when we were younger perhaps. Do you know what happens to an angry nerd girl who was frustrated until her sexual awakening, who’s had an ego boost because now she fits in somewhere? She commits verbal felonies.
In my experience, it’s hard not to tell an MTF. And for some reason I am more likely to call a drag queen “she” than a transgendered man. (And here’s the kick, i don’t even know if that is the right phrase, i just committed another oops moment. If it’s an MTF, is it a Trans man or a woman? I guess it is a woman because this blog is about Trans men.) There is something about “men” that stumps lesbians. When you know it’s there, you point it out. It’s a politically incorrect Where’s Waldo puzzle. When you see butches grabbing their crotches, you notice. When everyone has faux hawks, is wearing baseball hats, or wearing ties, you tally it up. Especially if you are less likely to do those things. You wonder why it seems like suddenly everyone has turned into teenage boys. It perplexes you. Because you are a woman, and you thought that was different than boy, even if a tomboy? And you are gay and into other woman. You didn’t date teenage boys when you were a teenager, yet they seem to be the pickings at the moment in this particular club you are in. And that’s neither here nor there of whom you may end up with; it is just that these are the ”faces” of lesbian right now. The cover models if you will.
We all know “The L Word” is a farce. There seemed to be very few things real about what they portrayed as couples. But what the “real” cover story of lesbian is, is the Trans movement and they did display that as part of the show. I for one feel as though we have been taken over, there was a mutiny somewhere, and this is coming from a reluctant lesbian and only a sometimes feminist. I for one hate our label/title. I’d rather just be gay and considered in the middle, not femme or butch.
It is not about what lesbians don’t have, it’s about what everyone else gets. There is resentment. It is difficult being a lesbian. Does anyone really talk about that? We’ve heard so much from the gay men’s “chorus” because they have cover models that go back to Rock Hudson. We have more men encroaching on our “turf” wanting to be women, and they seem to aim to be better at it than we are, meaning they follow a very traditional feminine role. I can’t apply makeup like some drag queens, gay men and MTFs! Then we haven’t even begun to talk about straight men who we tried to break out of the mold from. Additionally, you have a lot of butch/femme roles being played out in our community that seem stifling. Once you get to FTMs, it is just more of the same male dominance, and some of us have taken issue because we don’t understand what is happening to our community, our inner sanctum, the L in the whole GLBT. We hold womanliness and the feminine in high esteem. Not only that, but as Ls, we’ve had to fight for a different kind of woman, the kind that is not under a man’s thumb.
It’s the reaction of a flinching dog that has been yelled at too many times. There is so much masculinity in this world, and overtly sexualized femininity. We want to bite the hand of the Trans because it sometimes feels like the last straw. We’ve taken all we can of man. We want to keep some of the beauty, brains and power that FTMs hold within them, inside of our circle. We want your kink, your geek, your ego, your courage, your parts, your lips, your love to stay with us. It feels like a whole fleet of women are sailing away to discover a new world where men rule and they can be one of the ruling class. They leave us all waving on a separate shore, and we are not sure how to proceed. To come back to our land and announce “you will now call me sir”, well it’s just a little much to swallow and we are not used to swallowing.
To wrap this up, just like you, we are a work in progress. I personally have been finding myself intrigued by some FTMs. Some are extremely sexy to me, but usually not so much when they bulk up, but when they look like effeminate boys. I stayed up watching youtube until 6am listening to an angelic FTM talk about his surgery and taking T. I was mesmerized. I felt like I could still see his girl beauty, but he was an exquisite example of androgenous to me. When he spoke about his clit growing and having boners, I popped my own girl boner. But when he spoke about needing a bigger phallus and packing, my girl boner shrunk. This particular FTM had gone off of T. He looked like a skinny calvin klein model. I felt a combination of lust and calmness because he still seemed so soft. I watched subsequent videos after he went back on T and I lost my lust. He was scruffier, and looked more like a man growing into himself. Someone loves him. She could be a lesbian, or a straight girl, or a bi boy or another boi or a gay boy. He has the whole world to choose from and a majority of it to be a part of. We are just a little miffed that he turned his gorgeous back on us.
Krisiswriting